Can Shoulder Dystocia Lead to a Birth Injury Lawsuit in Illinois?

Shoulder dystocia can lead to an Illinois birth injury lawsuit if a healthcare provider's mistake caused harm to the baby or mother. However, this emergency sometimes happens even with proper medical care. A successful claim must show what the provider did wrong and how it caused an injury. If you or your child was injured during delivery in 2026, our Chicago birth injury lawyers can review the medical records and explain your options.
What Is Shoulder Dystocia During Childbirth?
Shoulder dystocia happens when a baby's head is delivered, but one shoulder becomes stuck behind the mother's pubic bone. The medical team must act quickly to free the shoulder and complete the delivery.
Doctors and nurses use specific techniques, such as moving the mother's legs toward her chest and applying pressure just above her pubic bone. They may also turn the baby's shoulders or deliver one arm first. These steps help create room for the baby.
Pulling too hard on the baby's head or pressing on the upper part of the mother's abdomen can cause harm. Still, the emergency itself does not mean someone made a mistake.
What Injuries Can Shoulder Dystocia Cause During Birth?
Shoulder dystocia can injure the baby or mother. Possible injuries include:
-
Brachial plexus injury, involving nerves that control the arm and hand
-
Erb's palsy or Klumpke's palsy, which affect different parts of the arm or hand
-
A broken collarbone or upper arm bone
-
Brain injury caused by a serious lack of oxygen during delivery
-
Severe vaginal tearing or heavy bleeding after birth
Many babies with nerve injuries recover movement, although some need surgery or long-term therapy. A serious injury may affect daily activities as the child grows.
Some injuries, including nerve damage, happen despite proper care. A diagnosis alone does not prove malpractice. Medical experts must examine how the delivery was handled.
When Does Shoulder Dystocia Qualify as Medical Malpractice in Illinois?
A lawsuit requires proof that a provider failed to meet accepted medical standards and that this failure caused an injury.
Risk factors include maternal diabetes, a very large baby, a previous shoulder dystocia, and a difficult labor. Providers should consider these risks when discussing delivery options. But shoulder dystocia is often unexpected. A larger estimated birth weight does not automatically require a cesarean delivery.
During delivery, the response matters. Experts may review how quickly help arrived, which techniques the team used, and whether unnecessary force was applied. The question is not simply whether an injury occurred, but whether different, appropriate care would have prevented it.
What Does Illinois Require Before Filing a Shoulder Dystocia Lawsuit?
Under 735 ILCS 5/2-622, a medical malpractice lawsuit usually requires a sworn statement from the attorney, called an affidavit. It must also include a written report from a qualified healthcare professional. The reviewer must study the relevant records and explain why there is a reasonable basis for the claim.
The expert must have relevant experience and must have practiced or taught in the same medical field within the past six years. A separate report is required for each provider or facility named in the lawsuit.
In limited situations, including when a filing deadline is approaching, Illinois permits the report to be submitted within 90 days after the lawsuit is filed. Missing the requirements can lead to dismissal.
How Long Do Families Have to File a Birth Injury Lawsuit in Illinois?
Under 735 ILCS 5/13-212, a child’s medical malpractice claim usually must be filed within eight years of the alleged mistake or by the child’s 22nd birthday, whichever comes first. For an injury at birth, this usually means filing by the child’s eighth birthday.
A mother’s claim for her own injuries has a different deadline. She usually has two years from when she knew or reasonably should have known about the injury to file. In most cases, she must also file within four years of the medical care that caused it.
Exceptions can change these deadlines, and claims involving government-run hospitals can follow different rules. An attorney can determine which deadline applies to your family’s case.
What Medical Records Help Prove a Shoulder Dystocia Birth Injury?
The prenatal records show known risk factors, ultrasound estimates, and discussions about delivery choices. Labor records help establish when the complication began and how the team responded.
Request the delivery notes, shoulder dystocia forms, fetal heart monitoring records, and newborn examinations. Later therapy reports and specialist evaluations help show the injury's lasting effects.
Ask for complete records in writing and keep copies of your requests. An attorney can help obtain missing records and arrange an expert review.
Schedule a Free Consultation With Our Chicago, IL Medical Malpractice Attorneys
Our attorneys have represented injured clients since 1997. We review delivery records, consult qualified medical professionals, and examine the child's treatment needs before advising families about a claim.
If shoulder dystocia caused an injury during your child's birth in 2026, contact Winters Salzetta O'Brien & Richardson, LLC at 312-236-6324 to talk to our Chicago birth injury lawyers.





